“The Shadow of What Was Lost” by James Islington

the-shadow-of-what-was-lostI’m always on the lookout for a good classic fantasy series. While I’m glad that so many books these days are not following the “hero’s journey of a secretly powerful young farmboy as the Dark One rises in a vaguely medieval world” trope, that trope is what got me into fantasy and it’s still my first love. It’s getting harder to write good books with that storyline, though – they end up being too clichéd, or too dark, or the characters are too wooden. When I read that The Shadow of What Was Lost was inspired by the Wheel of Time and Brandon Sanderson’s work (both of which I turn to for comfort reading), I was pretty excited to read it.

The Shadow of What Was Lost follows a group of three friends at a school for the Gifted (magic users) – Davian, Wirr, and Asha. Tragedy strikes and the friends become separated – Davian and Wirr on their way north on a quest they barely understand, and Asha taken to the royal capital determined to find out the truth of what happened. And the Boundary keeping out an ancient evil sorcerer and his hordes of evil creatures is starting to fail, and it doesn’t seem like it’s happening naturally.

I really enjoyed reading this book. It has an detailed world, interesting complementary magic (kind of like Robin Hobb’s Skill and Wit), and I cared about the characters. It isn’t entirely original (the Wheel of Time inspirations are occasionally pretty obvious), but the author puts his own spin on things and there were quite a few surprises as well. I liked that even though there were a few obvious Evil elements, most of the characters ended up having realistic motivations and things that seemed pretty black and white when they were introduced ended up have more depth to them. The author also doesn’t drag plot points on for very long – even if there are a few things that the reader learns that the characters don’t know yet, the characters find out within a few chapters (unlike the Wheel of Time; it’s excruciating when characters make decisions based on information we know to be incorrect as of a few books ago.)

I can’t wait to read book 2, An Echo of Things to Come, which should be released next year. I’m a little disappointed that the series is only planned to be a trilogy, I feel like the world and the characters are interesting enough to sustain a few more books.


The Shadow of What Was Lost by James Islington (The Licanius Trilogy, #1)
Orbit Books, 2016 | Buy the book
I received a complimentary review copy of this book.


Review & Giveaway: “Arcanum Unbounded” by Brandon Sanderson

Note: For instructions on how to enter the giveaway, see the bottom of this post.


arcanumunboundedIf you’ve been following my blog at all, you probably know that I’m a huge fan of pretty much everything Brandon Sanderson writes. I think it’s especially cool that many of his books are set on different planets in the same universe (the “Cosmere”), and that he plans to connect them all into an overarching story in the future. So when I found out that there was a Cosmere short fiction collection coming out, I was really excited to get it (even though I’ve already read many of the stories in it.)

First, I’ll talk about the book’s structure. I thought it would just be organized like a regular short story collection, but it actually has more. There are in-universe write ups (written by Khriss, the same woman who writes the Ars Arcanum at the end of all Brandon’s other books) about each planetary system featured in the book and how the magic there works. I’ve read a lot of Cosmere theories and interviews by Brandon about the Cosmere, and there’s quite a bit of information in these that has not been covered anywhere yet. Also, there are gorgeous illustrations for each story, and postscripts by Brandon about how the story came to be.

There’s one new novella in this book that has never been published before – Edgedancer, which is set in the world of the Stormlight Archive and features Lift, who we’ve met in an interlude in Words of Radiance. The Stormlight Archive is probably my favorite series by Brandon, so I was particularly excited to read this story, and of course it did not disappoint. It offers great moments of character growth, and it seems like it will be important to understand how a particular character’s attitude changes between Words of Radiance and the upcoming third book. Plus, Lift is a great character and I’d love to keep reading about her. Also, we see a few new things about Roshar, I wasn’t expecting more worldbuilding and answers from such a short story. My only complaint is that now I really, really cannot wait a year for the next book.

There were two other stories that were new to me, although they have been published previously in the Mistborn RPG books – The Eleventh Metal and Allomancer Jak and the Pits of Eltania. They were fun stories, I enjoyed The Eleventh Metal a bit more because it featured Kelsier, and who doesn’t love Kelsier? Allomancer Jak and the Pits of Eltania was a nice homage to pulp adventure, though.

I did reread all the stories I’d read previously as well. I absolutely love The Emperor’s Soul, I think it’s a really great standalone novella, and the fact that it’s set in the same world as Elantris and that it ties into the Cosmere just makes it better. The Hope of Elantris is a very simple story, but it’s cute, and it’s nice to see some of the backstory of what secondary characters were up to during the climax of Elantris. Mistborn: Secret History is pretty cool, I think it’s one of the first ones to actually delve directly into what’s going on with the Cosmere a little bit. I don’t want to say too much about it because even the protagonist’s name is a spoiler.

I guess White Sand will be new to a lot of readers, but it’s one of Brandon’s unpublished books that you can email him to get a copy of, and I’ve done that. It’s being published as a graphic novel series now, and the book excerpts both the graphic novel and the beginning of the unpublished book. I was afraid that the excerpt wouldn’t be satisfying enough by itself, but I think it manages to tell a good and complete story.

I first read Shadows for Silence in the Forests of Hell in George R.R. Martin and Gardner Dozois’ anthology Dangerous Women, and I love it. Threnody is a fascinating world, and the characters are different from the ones Brandon usually writes – darker and more serious. Sixth of the Dusk also has a very un-Brandon-like protagonist (someone who has trouble articulating himself), and the world is in a very interesting period as it evolves into the industrial age, prodded along by spacefaring humans. I think both of these stories are the most atmospheric in the book and I’d love to hear more from their world and characters in the future.

Overall, I’d highly recommend this collection. I think most of the stories would work for someone unfamiliar with Brandon Sanderson’s other work and the Cosmere just as well – the only ones I’d be iffy about are Mistborn: Secret History, which is set during the original Mistborn trilogy and probably doesn’t have much impact without reading it, and The Hope of Elantris, which is likewise set during Elantris.


Tor Books is letting me give away two copies of Arcanum Unbounded! To enter, please email me at kriti@justaworldaway.com with subject “Arcanum Unbounded” and your name and mailing address (US/Canada only). This giveaway is open until Dec 1, 2016.

“The Screaming Staircase” by Jonathan Stroud

screamingstaircaseI was a big fan of Jonathan Stroud’s Bartimaeus series when I was in (the Indian equivalent of) high school, so I’ve had his new Lockwood & Co. series on my wishlist for a while now. I’ve been reluctant to actually read it, though, because things I liked in school don’t always hold up when I read them now, and I didn’t want to tarnish my memories of Bartimaeus. My friend Sashank recently asked me to read and review the series on my blog, so I decided to take the plunge.

The world of The Screaming Staircase is very much like our own, except that for the past fifty years, dangerous ghosts have been haunting the world at an alarmingly high rate, and only children have the psychic sensitivity needed to sense and combat them effectively. We follow Lucy Carlyle, a fourteen year old Agent from the country that moves to London and joins the small Lockwood & Co. company. After one of their ghost investigations goes horribly wrong, they are forced to take on one of the country’s most haunted homes.

I read this book by flashlight at night during a power outage, and although it was fun in a terrifying kind of way, I don’t recommend it. I wouldn’t call the genre horror exactly – it’s supposed to be middle-grade, and it mostly focuses on the adventure, but there are some nail-bitingly creepy parts that Stroud really brings to life. I thought Lucy was a great protagonist, she’s earnest and vulnerable, she doesn’t take any crap from anyone but she’s not showy about it, either. Lockwood seems to be cut from similar cloth as Nathaniel in the Bartimaeus series, he’s self-possessed and precocious and you forget that he’s young until he does something ridiculous that makes you realize how young he is. I wanted to know more about George, but he seemed to get the short end of the stick (primarily because Lucy and Lockwood thrive on action, and George is the researcher they often ignore.)

I wasn’t that excited by the plot itself. There wasn’t anything notably bad about it, but I just wasn’t drawn into it that much. I was willing to forgive that because it’s clearly setting up a larger world and mysteries to explore. Overall, I’m glad to report that instead of tarnishing my memories of Stroud’s previous works, reading The Screaming Staircase just made me want to reread them.


The Screaming Staircase by Jonathan Stroud (Lockwood & Co., #1)
Disney-Hyperion, 2013 | Buy the book


“A World at Arms” by Gerhard Weinberg

a-world-at-armsAfter reading India After Gandhi, I was looking forward to learning about more contemporary history and I decided that World War II was the next topic on my agenda. World War II is prevalent enough in public consciousness that I knew a lot of random facts about it, but I wanted an overview of the war and how all the pieces fit together. I wasn’t sure where to start, but I found that the Ask Historians subreddit (which is pretty amazing) has a book recommendation list, which is where I found A World at Arms.

The recommendation entry for A World at Arms describes the book as “one of the best histories of the Second World War from a global perspective”, and although I haven’t read any other World War II histories, I would agree with that. Weinberg covers a vast scope – every theater and front, including the “home fronts” of all countries involved in the war, sociopolitical changes, international relations, economic changes, strategy, and so on. The book seemed meticulously researched, the references are extensive, and Weinberg often mentions which sources he used or did not have access to when proposing a theory for why something happened a certain way.

The writing style is somewhat dry, but there’s so much information packed into every paragraph that I didn’t mind at all. Even on days when I was only able to read 20 pages or so, I still felt like I was learning rapidly. Also, didn’t notice any huge biases by the author, which I found refreshing when compared to a lot of other non-fiction I’ve read. I guess it makes sense from such an academic book, though.

Because of the scope of the book, most of the detail in it is about high level strategy and machinations; there isn’t much of a perspective from the trenches. I happened to be watching the HBO miniseries Band of Brothers (which follows the American “Easy Company” attached to the 101st Airborne Division) at the same time that I was reading this book, though, and I found that to be a nice “on the ground” complement to the global view that A World at Arms offered.

Movies Watched: Aug 7 – Aug 13, 2016

[Aug 7] “Howl’s Moving Castle” (2004)

howls_moving_castleTimid hat maker Sophie is cursed to have the body of an old woman. In an effort to break the spell, she leaves home and ends up becoming the cleaning lady for the wizard Howl in his constantly moving castle. It turns out that she’s not the only one with a spell to break, though.

I think Howl’s Moving Castle was one of the earliest Ghibli movies I watched, and I hadn’t read the book (by Diana Wynne Jones) that it was based on at that point. I didn’t remember much from the movie, and I was pretty excited to watch it, especially because I had reread the book recently, and it’s one of my favorites. It was really hard for me to separate the movie and the book when watching it, but I’ll try, given that the movie isn’t anything like the book – it shares the premise at the beginning, but ends up going in a totally different direction before it comes back to the book at the end. The movie seemed to mainly tell an adventure story – there is a little personal growth (especially with Sophie), and some comedic scenes that are pretty funny, but overall it just seemed like stuff happened without the character motivations making a lot of sense. For example, in Spirited Away, Chihiro and Haku’s friendship makes sense, you see why they like each other, and the same applies to San and Ashitaka in Princess Mononoke but I didn’t see how Sophie and Howl ended up liking each other. Also, Howl’s character seemed pretty inconsistent, he has some of his obnoxiousness from the book (the infamous “green slime” scene), but there’s no real context for his vanity. His anti-war inclinations seemed way out of place too (in the book, Howl spends most of his time romancing women and then getting terrified every time they start to like him back and running away; there is no war.) And the villain’s motivation for both starting and ending the war didn’t seem to make any sense at all. Sophie’s character was good, although very different from the Sophie in the book.

I did enjoy the movie despite my complaints – I just had really high expectations due to both the book and previous Ghibli movies, and they were not met.

[Aug 8] “Carbon Copy” (1981)

Carbon_CopyA white corporate executive suddenly discovers that he has a black son who can’t wait to be adopted. When he tries to integrate him into his family, he loses his job, gets kicked out of the house, and discovers that he has no money. He has to figure out how to deal with everything he knows disappearing suddenly. We mainly watched this movie because it is Denzel Washington’s first movie (he plays the black son.) It’s mainly a comedy, although it does take a turn towards the dramatic at the end. It reminded me a little bit of Trading Places, but it’s not as good. The characters and situations exist entirely to serve the plot – for example (spoilers!), after rejecting the main character, his wife and father-in-law inexplicably show up again and ask him to come back to them, despite nothing having changed except that the main character has a little more confidence in himself now – enough to say no (end of spoilers). I did like Denzel’s character, he seemed consistent throughout.

[Aug 10] “American Splendor” (2003)

american_splendorThis movie tells the story of Harvey Pekar, the Cleveland author of the autobiographical American Splendor comics. It’s a pretty unusual biopic; it features both the real life Harvey Pekar (and his family and colleagues) commenting on some scenes, but mostly it stars Paul Giamatti as Pekar. I don’t think I’ve seen any other media that broke the fourth wall this blatantly, there barely even is a fourth wall. It’s a very good movie, I’m finding it hard to talk about because it seemed like I just saw a very well-edited video of someone’s real life, it doesn’t even seem like a movie. Paul Giamatti did an excellent job, as he always does (especially while playing sad/depressed characters), and Hope Davis was great as Pekar’s wife as well. Of course, it was great to see a movie set in and about Cleveland; there aren’t a lot of those. Highly recommended.

[Aug 11] “Executive Decision” (1996)

executive_decisionWhen terrorists hijack an airplane, intending to use it to release deadly nerve gas in Washington D.C., Dr. David Grant (Kurt Russell), an intelligence analyst, accompanies a mid-air boarding team sent to take control of the aircraft. Of course, things don’t go as planned and Grant ends up in a much more deadly situation than he signed up for.

Executive Decision is very much a dumb action movie; it’s a little bit like a Jack Ryan movie and a little bit like Air Force One, but it stars Kurt Russell, so that makes up for a lot of its shortcomings. The terrorist leader is played by David Suchet, who plays Poirot in the BBC series, and I really couldn’t take him seriously as a threat – he’s so mild mannered. Andreas Katsulas plays a captured terrorist leader (that Suchet’s character wants freed), and he’s also very mild mannered (plus I can’t not trust him, he plays G’Kar on Babylon 5, one of my favorite characters ever.) The rest of the cast is pretty great too – John Leguizamo, Halle Berry, BD Wong, etc. There isn’t much else notable to say, except that the scenes of Kurt Russell flying the planes seemed very realistic to me.

[Aug 12] “A Hologram for the King” (2016)

a-hologram-for-the-kingWashed out salesman Alan Clay (Tom Hanks) ends up in Saudi Arabia trying to sell a new IT system to the king in an effort to revive his career and pay for the rest of his daughter’s college tuition. He’s far away from home in a very strange culture, there’s a possibly malignant lump on his back, and he hates his life already. A Hologram for the King reminded me of Lost in Translation, which I love; it highlights the same sort of cultural differences and isolation, and the occasional absurdities of human interaction. Of course Tom Hanks is great – how could he not be? The movie didn’t have a very strong narrative, we see various incidents, but they don’t fit together to tell a simple story. There’s a little bit of a conclusion, but mostly it just shows life being life. I can see how that might turn some people off, but I actually really enjoyed it. Some things depicted in the movie seemed unlikely to happen in Saudi Arabia, but I liked the movie enough that I didn’t mind.

[Aug 13] “Criminal” (2016)

CriminalWhen CIA operative Bill Pope (Ryan Reynolds) is killed during an important mission, death row inmate Jericho Stewart (Kevin Costner) undergoes an experimental procedure to receive Pope’s memories in order to finish the mission. This is the second movie I’ve seen Ryan Reynolds in recently that involved transferring memories/consciousness between bodies, and this one is far better than Self/less (reviewed here.) It’s not a great movie by any means, but it’s fun. Kevin Costner is a little unbelievable at first as the incredibly dangerous Jericho, but as he starts processing his memories, he becomes much more familiar. The rest of the cast is great too – especially Gary Oldman and Tommy Lee Jones (playing an unusually passive character), who are reunited with Kevin Costner for the first time since JFK.  Some character motivations seemed pretty dumb (mostly Gary Oldman’s CIA boss who makes the worst decisions), but you kind of expect that from movies like this. Other than that, the movie avoids quite a few common tropes, and it actually explores the idea of implanting normal human memories into someone who doesn’t have the capacity for morality in an interesting way, so I’d recommend it.

Movies Watched: Jul 31 – Aug 6, 2016

[Jul 31] “Everest” (2015)

everestEverest is an ensemble movie based on the disastrous storm that struck several climbing expeditions on Mt. Everest in 1996. It primarily focuses on two commercial climbing teams – Adventure Consultants, led by Rob Hall (Jason Clarke), and Mountain Madness, led by Scott Fischer (Jake Gyllenhaal) and some of the mountaineers that were in their parties. It’s a very well made movie; the actors who played climbers all seemed like real people, they never overdo it despite the dramatic events surrounding them. The cast is great too – other than the people I’ve already mentioned, John Hawkes, Josh Brolin, Naoko Mori, Sam Worthington, and Michael Kelly all do a great job (I never thought I’d say that about Sam Worthington, I’ve been pretty underwhelmed by him in other movies.)

Most of what I took from the movie was an awe of Everest and mountaineering in general, though. There are so many ways to die – exhaustion, altitude sickness, falling, avalanches and storms – and people still choose to climb every year, and are okay with the risks of just being abandoned if disaster strikes (which makes sense given the risks, but is so alien to everyday morality.) Also, the Sherpas that actually prepare the mountain for climbing are even more amazing, since they don’t have the ropes and other equipment used by later climbers.

[Aug 1] “My Neighbors the Yamadas” (1999)

my-neighbors-the-yamadas We’re still full speed ahead on our Studio Ghibli movie watch. My Neighbors the Yamadas is a very different film than previous Ghibli movies both in narrative and animation styles. It lacks a single narrative, it’s a collection of short stories about the life of the zany Yamada family, similar to a newspaper comic strip. The animation also follows the comic strip style, it’s much more “cartoon” and lacks the detailed backgrounds that most other Ghibli movies have.

It took me a while to warm up to My Neighbors the Yamadas because I was not expecting something so different from previous movies, but it’s a good movie. The five members of the Yamada family are pretty frustrating at times, but only because they have all the foibles that you associate with people you know very well. I can’t think of another movie that does slice-of-life so well.

[Aug 4] “Spirited Away” (2001)

spirited-awayWhen her parents are turned into pigs while exploring an abandoned theme park, ten year old Chihiro must overcome her fear and navigate the spirit world to find a way to rescue them.

I was looking forward to watching Spirited Away, I think it was the very first Miyazaki movie I watched, but I didn’t remember much of it. One of the things I love about Miyazaki is that each of his movies has a different tone, and I think Spirited Away manages to combine the best of many of them – the adventure from Castle in the Sky, the world-building of Princess Mononoke, the magic of Kiki’s Delivery Service. It’s also beautiful and atmospheric in its own unique way – I can play back a couple of eerie scenes in my head at will (along with the music, the soundtrack is great!), which I can’t do with most movies. Chihiro is a good protagonist, she has different things to learn than many of the (older) protagonists of other Ghibli movies, but she does grow. The other characters are memorable too, especially No Face, who was the only thing I remembered from the first watch. This is definitely one of Miyazaki’s best movies.

[Aug 5] “The Cat Returns” (2002)

The-Cat-ReturnsHigh school student Haru’s life isn’t going very well – she feels like she’s picked on constantly, and she can’t summon the courage to talk to the boy she has a crush on. When she saves the life of a cat who turns out to be the prince of the Cat Kingdom, her life goes even crazier when she’s kidnapped and involuntarily engaged to the prince. Her only hope of salvation lies with the living cat statue Baron Humbert von Gikkingen and his friends Muta and Toto.

The Cat Returns is a spinoff of Whisper of the Heart (reviewed last week), sort of. It’s a totally unrelated story except for starring two minor characters from the movie – the Baron and Muta. I like to think it’s an adaption of another story that Shizuku wrote featuring the Baron. Anyway, it’s not comparable to most Ghibli movies, the character design is a lot more like traditional anime. The storyline and characters are fairly light too, there aren’t many layers to it. I think it’s more similar to a Disney animated movie, and it’s pretty fun for what it is. I especially liked seeing the Baron again.

[Aug 6] “13 Hours: The Secret Soldiers of Benghazi” (2016)

thirteen_hours_the_secret_soldiers_of_benghazi13 Hours is based on the true story of the September 11, 2012 attacks on the US diplomatic compound and CIA annex in Benghazi, Libya. The U.S. Ambassador to Libya was killed, and six CIA security contractors (ex-soldiers) held off waves of further attacks.

I didn’t know much about the Benghazi attacks, and I enjoyed this movie from a “learning about events” perspective. From what I’ve been able to gather, the movie is actually pretty faithful to real events (although the events themselves are controversial.) However, this movie is also directed by Michael Bay, so I didn’t expect it to be very good from a human perspective, and it wasn’t. It’s much better than Pearl Harbor (his previous combat movie), but there’s gratuitous slow motion and clichéd conversations between the soldiers and their families (which had the opposite effect on me, it made me care about them less because they seemed so fake), and the dialogue is laughable at times. When it was focusing on the action, the movie was great, it really brought home the confusion of modern warfare where you don’t know who your enemy is. The cast was pretty amazing too, I especially enjoyed James Badge Dale as the intense leader of the soldiers,  Tyrone “Rone” Woods.

Movies Watched: Jul 24 – Jul 30, 2016

[Jul 24] “The Bourne Ultimatum” (2007)

the-bourne-ultimatumAfter the events of The Bourne Supremacy, Jason Bourne is on the run and still trying to track down what’s going on with Treadstone and his past. When journalist Simon Ross finds out about the Treadstone successor program Blackbriar, Bourne gets a lead, but is soon dodging evil CIA officials and assassins again. I liked this movie a lot more than The Bourne Supremacy, it was very well paced, giving Bourne just enough information to keep the mystery intriguing all the way through. I liked the way that it wove together the end of the previous movie – at the beginning, Bourne is escaping from Moscow after talking with Neski’s daughter, and the epilogue scene where he talks to Landy is actually in the middle of The Bourne Ultimatum, and it’s integral to the plot. I wasn’t a big fan of the shaky cam and quick cuts (continued from the previous movie), and I found the action scenes similarly hard to follow, but that didn’t matter so much because of the better pacing.

[Jul 25] “Porco Rosso” (1992)

Porco_RossoAnother Studio Ghibli movie, and probably one of the least well known Miyazaki movies. We follow Porco Rosso, who is an ace seaplane pilot and bounty hunter off the coast of Italy in the 1930s.  He also happens to be cursed to be an anthropomorphic pig. When brash American pilot Donald Curtis shows up, he quickly becomes Porco Rosso’s rival in flying, courting women, and in the bounty hunting business, and Porco has to figure out how to deal with that. I thought this would be a movie aimed squarely at children, what with the protagonist being a pig, but it’s actually exactly the opposite. There’s adventure and pirates and cool flying and so on, but Porco is a curmudgeonly character (voiced masterfully by Michael Keaton) with some pretty serious flaws, which makes him interesting, but definitely not straightforward. The other characters are great too, I especially liked Fio – Miyazaki really does spunky young women like no one else. Cary Elwes seems like he’s having a lot of fun voicing Curtis. I also liked the ending a lot, there’s no grand triumph, but it ends very nicely. I’m not sure why more people don’t talk about this movie.

[Jul 26] “The Bourne Legacy” (2012)

the_bourne_legacyWe found out today that the fifth Bourne movie, Jason Bourne, is releasing this week, and since we’ve coincidentally been on a Bourne kick lately, we figured that we might as well catch up on the series completely. Jason Bourne is not actually in this movie, it’s about operative Aaron Cross (played by Jeremy Renner) from a related project, Operation Outcome. As the revelations about Treadstone and Bourne are revealed to the world, all the Outcome operatives are taken out to hide the truth of the program. Of course, Aaron Cross escapes and now he’s on the run. I liked this movie in a lot of ways; it expands the world of Bourne, it integrates tightly with the other Bourne movies (this series is really good at that), there are a lot more interesting settings, Jeremy Renner is charming, and Rachel Weisz plays a realistic-seeming scientist that actually seems passionate about her technobabble. I went into it expecting Aaron Cross to be another Jason Bourne, but the programs seem pretty different – Treadstone seemed more about assassination, whereas Outcome was about intelligence gathering – so Cross knows who he is, he smiles often, he doesn’t seem to have been brainwashed, he’s just genetically enhanced. That makes for a pretty different type of story, but once I got used to it, I enjoyed it. I thought the end could have been better and had more closure – I wasn’t clear why they would have stopped looking for him.

[Jul 28] “Pom Poko” (1994)

pompokoPom Poko follows a population of raccoon dogs (tanuki) who live in the Tama Hills outside of Tokyo. As the city is expanding, Tama Hills is scheduled to be cleared and leveled to build a high density suburb, which would leave the tanuki homeless. The tanuki decide to fight back, some using their amazing transformative powers to “haunt” the area, and others fighting back in more violent ways.

I watched this movie a really long time ago, before I know much about anime, and I remember thinking it was extremely weird (especially the magical expanding scrota of the tanuki.) It’s actually a pretty compelling movie, and all the things I found odd before didn’t even register as notable this time around. The movie can be read as having an environmentalist message, but I think it’s more about seeing how a population reacts to rapid and inevitable societal change.  It’s never nice to see animals lose their habitat, but the movie doesn’t dwell on the sadness, instead focusing on the tanuki living life to the fullest despite their circumstances. We see the stories of many different tanuki without moral judgement on their choices, and that ends up making the overall movie a lot more nuanced than others I’ve seen.

[Jul 29] “Whisper of the Heart” (1995)

whisper-of-the-heartWhisper of the Heart is the next Studio Ghibli movie, and the first non-Miyazaki or Takahata directed movie (although it was written by Miyazaki.)  Shizuku, a girl who loves reading books notices that the same person (Seiji Amasawa) has checked out all the same books as her. In parallel, she meets an infuriating boy that’s in her grade, who of course turns out to be Seiji.

I’ve seen this movie before, but I don’t think I understood how good it was until I watched it this time. It’s a sweet and subtle romance, but it’s also a coming of age movie – like Kiki in Kiki’s Delivery Service, Shizuku must come to terms with herself, but Whisper of the Heart portrays that growth in the context of having good relationships with others. The relationship between Shizuku and Seiji seemed completely natural to me, showing strong emotion without any melodrama. I enjoyed the other characters too – Shizuku’s parents and sister (and their relationships with Shizuku), Seiji’s grandfather and his story with Louise, and especially the Baron.

[Jul 30] “Princess Mononoke” (1997)

princess_mononokeAnother Studio Ghibli/Miyazaki movie (and arguably the most famous one.) Prince Ashitaka must travel far to the west to find a cure for a curse that he acquired while protecting his village from a demon. Once he gets there, he finds himself in the middle of a fight between a mining colony and the inhabitants of the local forest. The inhabitants of the forest are mainly animals and spirit gods, but one of them is San (Princess Mononoke), a human girl raised by wolves.

As with Pom Poko, one of Princess Mononoke‘s themes is man’s relationship with nature and the inevitability of loss as man progresses. Neither side is portrayed as good or bad – the main enemy is just a refusal to compromise. San and the animal spirits are enraged and violent at the loss of their forest, and Lady Eboshi is willing to do whatever it takes to ensure that her settlement and factory is not threatened. But she is also kind and protective of her workers, and works with people that no one else will – ex-prostitutes and lepers. Just like Ashitaka, you end up admiring both San and Lady Eboshi, but despair whether they can ever find common ground.  The soundtrack is fantastic – it’s much more epic than the previous movies. Also, the movie was adapted to English by Neil Gaiman, which means it flows extremely well, although many references to Japanese folklore and tradition were removed to make the story more accessible. I don’t think this is the most enjoyable Ghibli movie, but it’s definitely one of the best ones.

Movies Watched: Jul 17 – Jul 23, 2016

[Jul 17] “Kiss Kiss Bang Bang” (2005)

kiss_kiss_bang_bangHarry Lockhart (Robert Downey Jr.) is a petty thief who accidentally stumbles into an audition to play a detective and gets flown to L.A. and thrust suddenly into the life of an actor, including detective lessons from consultant “Gay” Perry (Val Kilmer). Life takes a turn for the storybook when he runs into an old high school crush and stumbles into a murder mystery. This movie was fantastic! It blends genres effortlessly, it’s a dark comedy (narrated by Lockhart who breaks the fourth wall constantly), it’s pulpy murder mystery involving sexy women, it’s noir, and it also manages to inject a bunch of heart into the proceedings by making Lockhart a genuinely nice guy. Val Kilmer, is great as always as the hard boiled detective (except for swooning over the occasional guy) who takes no shit from anyone, especially Lockhart. Michelle Monaghan is also good as the high school crush/failed actress Harmony Faith Lane, and she certainly has chemistry with Robert Downey Jr.

[Jul 18] “The Pianist” (2002)

the-pianistThe Pianist is based on the true story of a Polish Jewish musician, Wladyslaw “Wladek” Szpilman (Adrien Brody), and his survival in Warsaw during World War II. As with any Holocaust story, this is not a pleasant movie to watch – we watch as Wladek and his family go from fairly prosperous members of society to being forced to identify themselves as Jews in public and kowtow to capricious Germans to being forcibly relocated into the ghetto to being deported to labor camps and so on. I really admired this movie for not losing its focus though – it tells Wladek’s story, not the story of the war, or the Holocaust, and it never deviates from that. That makes it intensely personal, especially because we know what’s going on around him and how it all turns out, but he doesn’t know what’s going to happen next. Adrien Brody is incredible, he conveys a lot of nuance, and there are scenes where he’s absolutely visceral. The end of the movie shows a little humanity in contrast to all the brutality so far, and that’s nice too (especially because it’s based on real life too.) Highly recommended.

[Jul 19] “Kiki’s Delivery Service” (1989)

Kiki's Delivery ServiceKiki is a young witch who must leave home for a year to make her way in the world, as per tradition. She finds the perfect city to settle in and starts an delivery service (using her broom to fly packages places), but she finds it hard to adjust to life in her new community. We thought we would skip Kiki’s Delivery Service during our Studio Ghibli chronological watch because we’ve watched it so many times before, but we just couldn’t. I can’t really review this movie objectively; it’s probably my favorite movie of all time. Yes, all time! Kiki’s story is infinitely relatable, we’ve all felt like we didn’t fit in and been overwhelmed, we’ve all felt a loss of purpose and self-esteem, and we’ve all disliked other people irrationally because they remind us (in whatever roundabout way) of something we don’t like about ourselves. The setting is somewhat fantastic, but the world depicted is just like ours – there are nice people, stuck up people, self-absorbed people, slightly-crazy-but-not-in-a-bad-way people, and Kiki has to learn to accept that world for what it is (a pretty great place if you focus on the right things.) Plus, Jiji (Kiki’s black cat) is fantastic – especially in the English dub, where he’s played more sarcastically. I could go on and on, but I’ll stop here.

[Jul 21] “8 Mile” (2002)

8-mileJimmy “Bunny Rabbit” Smith (Eminem) is a young man that’s having a hard time with his life – his work, his girlfriend, his relationship with his mom, and most importantly, his avocation – rapping. After he chokes completely during a rap battle he enters, he doesn’t really know what to do with himself. Joseph has been wanting to watch this movie for a long time, and I’ve been very skeptical – Eminem starring in a movie that seems pretty much based on his life? I was convinced it would be some sort of dumb vanity project, but this movie is actually pretty good. Eminem is utterly convincing as the angry and scared Jimmy, and you really root for him to figure himself out and escape his circumstances. When he finally does, you know he’s earned it and really accepted himself.  The setting is gritty but feels realistic (I wouldn’t know if it actually was), the rap battles are fast paced and compelling. It was a little bit weird to see Anthony Mackie (in his first movie) as the antagonist, because I’m so used to him being lovable, but that’s okay.

[Jul 22] “The Bourne Supremacy” (2004)

the_bourne_supremacyThe first of many sequels to The Bourne Identity. Bourne and Marie are living in peace in India when an assassin sent to kill Bourne accidentally ends up killing Marie instead. Bourne is convinced that Treadstone has reneged on their promise to leave him alone, but the truth isn’t quite so simple. I liked this movie okay, I don’t think it was as good as the first one. It did several things well, though – it is one of the most tightly integrated sequels I’ve ever seen, it feels very much like a part of Bourne’s overall story rather than just a new adventure. I also love the “mystery” part of these movies, where Bourne has to figure out what’s actually going on. Also, Joan Allen makes a fantastic CIA agent; I’ve only seen her as an unhappy wife before (Nixon, Pleasantville, The Upside of Anger). I think the pacing for the last third of the movie was bad, though – the plot with the CIA wraps up before the last act of the movie, and the last act seems kind of pointless. I found the car chase at the end very confusing, it seemed to go on forever, but it also seemed like each cut only lasted a second, and I had no idea what was going on. Plus, if you’re going to have Karl Urban in a movie, don’t cut off his hair, his hair is beautiful (and don’t make him some dumb bad guy either.)

[Jul 23] “Mr. Magorium’s Wonder Emporium” (2007)

mr-magoriums-wonder-emporiumMr. Magorium (Dustin Hoffman), the 243 year old owner of the magical toy store Mr. Magorium’s Wonder Emporium has decided that his time has come and he must leave the store to Molly Mahoney (Natalie Portman), the store’s insecure 23 year old manager. Both the store and Molly have other ideas, though. Apparently a lot of people didn’t like this movie, but I absolutely loved it. Sure, it has flaws – it’s odd and random, it’s a little bit cliched at times, but it’s cute, it has a good message about believing in yourself, and the cast is great! No one can do weird and wonderful characters better than Dustin Hoffman (see Hook if you don’t believe me), and everyone else is quirky and wonderful too, especially Jason Bateman as the accounting “Mutant” and Zach Mills as the earnest and precocious kid Eric. Plus, the toy store itself is definitely a character, and it’s amazing! It reminded me of being a kid and being curious about everything around me, there’s crazy stuff everywhere you look. It also reminded me of a lot of books I’d read, like The Phantom Tollbooth, or Catherynne M. Valente’s Fairyland series.

Movies Watched: Jul 10 – Jul 16, 2016

[Jul 10] “Donnie Darko” (2001)

Donnie-DarkoDonnie Darko (Jake Gyllenhaal) is a troubled teenager that starts having visions of a giant bunny rabbit that saves his life and then induces him to commit various crimes. That isn’t a great description of the movie, but I don’t know how to describe it any better, it’s a pretty strange movie. We watched the director’s cut, which adds twenty minutes of footage, and apparently makes an originally ambiguous movie much less ambiguous (it was my first time watching the movie, but Joseph had seen the theatrical cut before.) I’m still not sure what I think of it, it was definitely made very well, and it made me think, but it also made me feel confused and upset once it was over. It’s not a movie that believes in explaining how it works, and I usually have trouble with that, but the fact that it was able to get me to feel so strongly about it means that it actually did a good job of making me care about the characters and invest in the plot. I’m glad I watched it.

[Jul 11] “Tootsie” (1982)

tootsieWhen unemployed actor Michael Dorsey (Dustin Hoffman) is unable to get any work, he decides to impersonate a woman and audition for a role in a soap opera. He ends up getting the role, and his experience as a woman ends up changing both his life and the lives of others around him. Tootsie is definitely a comedy, but I appreciated that it had some heart to it. Dustin Hoffman does a fairly convincing job as a woman, he changes his voice and mannerisms quite a bit. The romance was a little bit weird, it’s hard to imagine falling in love with someone who has presented themselves completely differently from who they really are. Also, a lot of the humor comes off as dated, but then, this movie is over 30 years old.

[Jul 12] “The Disappearance of Haruhi Suzumiya” (2010)

the-disappearance-of-haruhi-suzumiyaThe Disappearance of Haruhi Suzumiya is a follow up to the anime show The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya, which we had just finished watching. Kyon wakes up one day to find out that the world around him is entirely different – Haruhi and Koizumi are nowhere to be found, and the alien Miss Nagato and the time traveler Miss Asahina are now completely normal people, and no one remembers the world being any different.  Like the other anime based movies I’ve seen, I can’t review this as a standalone movie, but I think it does make an effort to be standalone – it introduces the world of Haruhi pretty well before jumping into the main plot, and it tells a conclusive story without depending on the events of the show (the show doesn’t have much of an overarching plot anyway). I absolutely loved this movie. It was definitely nice to see all my favorite characters again, but I think it would have been a great movie regardless. Being stuck in an alternate universe is a pretty common trope, but that’s a terrifying thought in reality, and the movie does a great job of showing how freaked out Kyon is. There’s a lot of emotional depth and character growth; it’s nice to see Kyon go from his usual passive observer role to having to be the agent of change. Also, the pacing is phenomenal – The Disappearance of Haruhi Suzumiya is the second longest animated movie ever made (at almost three hours), but it’s never boring or drawn out. I want more!

[Jul 13] “Breakdown” (1997)

breakdownBreakdown is an action movie starring Kurt Russell as a guy whose wife goes missing after his car breaks down in the middle of nowhere. The last time he sees her is when she gets into a truck that has stopped to help them, but when he sees the trucker again, he claims to have no knowledge of his wife and denies even having met him at all. This was a fine movie, I don’t have a lot to say about it. Kurt Russell does a good job of going from a normal somewhat inept guy to trying riskier and riskier things as he gets more desperate. The movie soon dispenses with the fiction that no one knows what’s going on, there isn’t a lot of nuance in the movie, and the bad guys are unambiguously bad.

[Jul 14] “The Darjeeling Limited” (2007)

the_darjeeling_limitedThree dysfunctional brothers travel across India a year after their father’s funeral in an effort to become closer together. The Darjeeling Limited was the first Wes Anderson movie that I saw, and I saw it before I really understood movies, or his style. I just thought it was weird, so I was looking forward to seeing it again and developing a more nuanced opinion. I still think it is one of his weaker movies – it has characters that you kind of hate, but unlike Rushmore or The Royal Tenenbaums or The Grand Budapest Hotel, I never really stopped hating them. Maybe it’s because both me and Joseph are only children and don’t understand sibling rivalries as much. Also, I get that the movie is a surreal journey but I didn’t like the portion of the story with the child’s death (other than to see Irrfan Khan), it seemed out of place to use that as just a bonding experience.

[Jul 15] “The Last Emperor” (1987)

the-last-emperorThe Last Emperor is about the life of Puyi, the last emperor of China, who became emperor when he was two and only ruled for four years before he was overthrown (other than a 12 day reign when he was 11). His life didn’t stop being interesting there, he was later recruited by Japan to be the emperor of its puppet state, Manchukuo until the end of World War II. I didn’t know anything about Puyi or his life, so this was a fascinating watch, and it was also a very good movie – it won the Best Picture Oscar. All the actors portraying Puyi did an excellent job, and the movie is an emotional experience as we watch him go from an innocent child to being spoiled and entitled and then back to being humbled. The movie is (mostly) told through a series of flashbacks from Puyi’s life in rehabilitation for being a war criminal, and the use of different color palettes for different periods of his life adds a subtle atmosphere without being distracting like it was in Traffic. The sets and costumes are beautiful, too.

We watched the theatrical edition, which was nearly three hours long. There’s a longer cut (3 hours and 38 minutes) of the movie that was meant to be aired as a miniseries, I’d like to watch that at some point too.

[Jul 16] “WALL-E” (2008)

wall_eWALL-E is a trash compactor robot who is all alone on Earth other than neverending piles of trash and a cockroach. One day, another robot (EVE) lands on the planet and his life changes forever. He ends up going on a journey into space and having a major effect on the fate of humanity. I’d never seen this movie before (other than watching the first twenty minutes on a plane once), and it’s part of our ongoing “watch all the Pixar movies” project. I remember hearing a lot of fuss about how it was a really amazing movie because the main characters had basically no dialogue, and that’s true, but I didn’t notice it (which I guess was the point.) It was a cute movie, EVE especially was a great character. WALL-E was fine too, but he’s just the classic, somewhat bumbling, underdog. My favorite scene was the one where they are cavorting in space, you’ll know which one if you see the movie.

The fate of humanity made me very sad, so I feel like I didn’t enjoy the movie as much as I would have otherwise. Also, the antagonist seemed a little forced.

“India After Gandhi” by Ramachandra Guha

India-After-GandhiI’ve been wanting to learn more about history for a long time now, and I’ve finally decided to take the plunge and start reading more history books. I started off with a book I’ve owned for about eight years now, but never got around to reading. I think I’ve been avoiding non-fiction because it takes me much longer to read and comprehend it, but I guess I should stop judging my reading by total number of books read.

India After Gandhi is a post-independence history of India; a subject I didn’t know a lot about, despite spending the first seventeen years of my life there. In school, our history books pretty much stopped at independence. It starts off with the Partition and the formation of the Indian government, and goes until 2007 (when the book was written), although the final two decades are not covered with the same level of historical detail (due to the events being too contemporary.)

The book is extremely comprehensive, Guha clearly did a lot of research – the bibliography is humongous. It covered the process of transitioning from British rule (highlighting administrative problems like integrating over 550 kingdoms into India, setting up free and fair elections for a largely illiterate electorate, and settling millions of refugees from Partition), subsequent politics, economic policy, social movements, and there’s even a chapter on popular entertainments. I learned a lot, I’m certainly a long way away from knowing all that I want to know about Indian history, but I feel like I have a solid foundation on which to build on, and I wouldn’t have thought one book would have been able to do that. It also gave me the historical context to understand several things I’d been confused about when I lived in India (like the history of the political parties and how they came to have the positions they did, and how the Indian states came to be organized in their current configuration.)

Guha does an admirable job of approaching things from a historian’s point of view, you can see that he has his own opinions as an Indian citizen, but he makes it pretty obvious that they are his own opinions when they crop up. I’m sure there are biases in what he chose to talk about and how he presented it, but those are unavoidable. My only complaint on that front was that Guha chooses to emphasize India’s successes, but doesn’t spend as much time talking about India’s failures. It’s not like he doesn’t acknowledge them, but because he doesn’t give them as much detail, they come across as relatively unimportant. For example, at one point he mentions that an election would be the first “free and fair” election in Kashmir, but all the talk of previous elections in the book so far had been about the heroic efforts of India’s Election Commission to set up elections that actually worked, so how did the Kashmir elections end up unfair?

Overall, I thought that this was a great book, and I’d recommend it to anyone looking to learn more about India. It did make me very sad, though – seeing India start out with such well-intentioned and smart leaders and devolve into the mess that it is now.


India After Gandhi by Ramachandra Guha
Picador, 2007 | Buy the book